09 October 2026

Finding the right people in maritime isn’t always straightforward.

Sometimes the challenge is the experience you need. Sometimes it’s location, salary, availability or competition for a particularly small group of people. And some appointments simply matter too much to get wrong.

When a search isn’t producing the people you expected, it can be tempting to keep going and hope the right person appears.

Before you do it, it’s worth taking a step back.

There are usually things you can learn from the search so far that can help you decide what to do next.

​

1. Go back to the brief

Start with what you’re asking the market for.

Which parts of the brief are essential and which are desirable?

In maritime, specific requirements can quickly narrow the available talent pool. Location, sector experience, technical knowledge, leadership experience, salary expectations and willingness to relocate can all have an impact.

The brief may be right. But it’s better to know that because you’ve tested it against the market rather than simply assuming it is.

​

2. Understand the size of the market

Before changing the role or lowering expectations, find out who is actually available.

Who has the experience you need? Where are they based? What would encourage them to consider a move? How competitive is your offer? And how many people genuinely fit the brief?

An established maritime talent network gives you a strong starting point, particularly in specialist areas where knowledge of the sector matters.

For more difficult appointments, market mapping can take that further, building a clearer picture of where the right people are and what it might take to attract them.

Knowing the market puts you in a much better position to decide what happens next.

​

3. Look at what’s stopping people from saying yes

A difficult search doesn’t necessarily mean there aren’t suitable people.

Something else could be getting in the way.

It could be:

  • Salary

  • Location or relocation

  • Scope of the role

  • Seniority

  • The experience being requested

  • Competition elsewhere in the market

  • The way the opportunity is being presented

Look back at the conversations you’ve already had with candidates.

If the same concerns keep appearing, don’t ignore them. They can tell you where the search needs to change.

​

4. Look beyond people who are ready to move

For some maritime appointments, the right person may not currently be considering a move.

They may be settled in their current role, not actively searching or simply unaware that an opportunity exists.

That’s why a difficult search sometimes needs to reach beyond people who are actively in the market.

Identifying people with the right experience and having a direct conversation with them can open up a different part of the talent pool, particularly for specialist, senior or business-critical maritime appointments.

It also gives you a better understanding of the market. Are people interested in the opportunity? What would encourage them to move? Are there aspects of the role or package that are making the decision more difficult?

Those conversations can be just as valuable as the eventual shortlist.

​

5. Decide what needs to change

By this point, you should have a clearer idea of what’s making the search difficult.

It might be the brief. The available talent pool. Salary or location. The way the opportunity is being presented. Or simply that the people with the experience you need aren’t actively looking.

The next step isn’t necessarily to start again. It’s to decide what needs to change.

That might mean:

  • Revisiting part of the brief

  • Looking at salary or location

  • Widening the geographical search

  • Considering people from adjacent maritime sectors

  • Approaching people who aren’t actively looking

  • Spending more time mapping the available talent market

  • Changing the way the search is run

The important thing is to make the decision based on what you‘ve learnt from the market, rather than hoping another few weeks will produce a different result.

​

Before you restart the search, ask these seven questions:
​
1. Is the brief realistic?

Are the skills, experience, location and salary aligned with the people available in the market?

2. Do you know how big the talent pool really is?

A lack of applications doesn’t necessarily mean the people aren’t out there.

3. What have candidates told you so far?

Look for recurring reasons why good people have declined, withdrawn or decided not to pursue the opportunity.

4. Are you reaching people who aren’t actively looking?

The right person may need to be identified and approached directly.

5. Which parts of the brief could you flex?

Be clear about what’s essential and where there is room to move.

6. What happens if the role stays vacant?

Consider the effect on your existing team, projects, customers and commercial plans.

7. Is it time to change the way you’re searching?

If you’ve identified the problem but the current approach can’t solve it, a more dedicated search may be the next step.

​

When a dedicated search makes sense

Some maritime appointments need greater focus.

The role might be particularly important to the business. The people with the right experience may be difficult to find. You may need to approach a very specific part of the market, understand who’s available before making decisions, or manage the search confidentially.

​

Taking your maritime search further

Retained search gives employers a dedicated search for appointments that need greater focus, research and market coverage.

At Faststream, that means building on the maritime network, relationships and market knowledge we’ve developed over decades, while dedicating additional research and market mapping to the people most relevant to the appointment.

Got a difficult role on your desk?

Talk to our team about the role.

​

Back to insights

Share this Insight

Meet the author

Banner Default Image

Register to receive insights